Advantage Shake
Atkins
VS
Energy Shake
Nature's Plus
Advantage Shake
Atkins
VS
Energy Shake
Nature's Plus
[Atkins] Advantage Shake VS Energy Shake [Nature's Plus]
2.5 VSR
VSRating
3.4 VSR
$ 5.82
Price
per pure 25g protein
$ 1.86
15 g
Protein
per serving size
16 g
$ 3.49
Price
per serving size
$ 1.19
No
Amino Acids / BCAAs
No
No
Enzymes / Probiotics
No
Yes
2 Mineral(s): Sodium, Potassium
Vitamins / Minerals
Yes
12 Vitamin(s): Vitamin A, Vitamin D2, Vitamin B1, Vitamin B3, Vitamin B9, Vitamin B7, Vitamin C, Vitamin E, Vitamin B2, Vitamin B6, Vitamin B12, Vitamin B5
11 Mineral(s): Sodium, Potassium, Calcium, Magnesium, Selenium, Chromium, Iron, Iodine, Zinc, Manganese, Molybdenum
11 Mineral(s): Sodium, Potassium, Calcium, Magnesium, Selenium, Chromium, Iron, Iodine, Zinc, Manganese, Molybdenum
Yes
5 Flavor(s): Cafe Caramel Shake, Dark Chocolate Royale, French Vanilla Shake, Milk Chocolate, Strawberry Shake
Flavors
No
Yes
1 Size(s): 4 Container(s)
Sizes
Yes
1 Size(s): 1.7 lb
Our verdict
We’ve conducted an analysis of Atkins Advantage Shake and Nature's Plus Energy Shake. 2.5 VSR - that’s how many Atkins Advantage Shake receives, so he wins, its competitor Nature's Plus Energy Shake gains 3.4 VSR. The gap in rating was affected in the first place by the price of protein, thus 25 grams of pure protein of Atkins Advantage Shake will cost you $ 5.82, as against $ 1.86 of Nature's Plus Energy Shake. One serving of Atkins Advantage Shake contains 15 grams protein as against 16 grams in one Nature's Plus Energy Shake serving. For a serving of Atkins Advantage Shake you will pay $ 3.49 , and a for a serving of Nature's Plus Energy Shake you will have to pay $ 1.19.
The Atkins Advantage Shake composition contains minerals in an amount of 2 as against 11 in Nature's Plus Energy Shake.
Also Nature's Plus Energy Shake contains vitamins in an amount of 12.
Atkins produces 5 flavors of Advantage Shake. Nature's Plus Energy Shake has no taste, the manufacturer produces it unflavored.
Atkins Advantage Shake and Nature's Plus Energy Shake have only one size, Atkins Advantage Shake has 4 container(s) and Nature's Plus Energy Shake has 1.7 lb.
We recommend buying Nature's Plus Energy Shake.
Same Nutrition Facts
160
calories
70
90
calories from fat
0
240 mg
sodium
150 mg
Effective for: Low levels of sodium in the blood
Possibly Effective for: Cystic fibrosis
Possibly Effective for: Cystic fibrosis
790 mg
potassium
150 mg
Effective for: Low levels of potassium in the blood
Possibly Effective for: Stroke; High blood pressure
Possibly Effective for: Stroke; High blood pressure
5 g
total carbohydrate
2 g
15 g
protein
16 g
Difference Nutrition Facts
Only in nutrition
Advantage Shake Atkins
Advantage Shake Atkins
Total Fat
10 g
Saturated Fat
3.5 g
Cholesterol
15 mg
Dietary Fiber
3 g
Sugars
1 g
Only in nutrition
Energy Shake Nature's Plus
Energy Shake Nature's Plus
Other Carbohydrates
2 g
Vitamin A
5000 IU
Effective for: Vitamin A deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Breast cancer; Cataracts; Measles; Precancerous lesions in the mouth ; Overall mortality; Diarrhea after giving birth; Pregnancy-related death; Pregnancy-related night blindness; Eye disease affecting the retina
Possibly Effective for: Breast cancer; Cataracts; Measles; Precancerous lesions in the mouth ; Overall mortality; Diarrhea after giving birth; Pregnancy-related death; Pregnancy-related night blindness; Eye disease affecting the retina
Calcium
300 mg
Effective for: Indigestion; High levels of potassium in the blood; Low levels of calcium in the blood; Kidney failure
Possibly Effective for: Colon cancer, rectal cancer; High cholesterol; High blood pressure; Preventing tooth loss; Overactive parathyroid; Weak and brittle bones; Premenstrual syndrome
Possibly Effective for: Colon cancer, rectal cancer; High cholesterol; High blood pressure; Preventing tooth loss; Overactive parathyroid; Weak and brittle bones; Premenstrual syndrome
Vitamin D2
400 IU
Effective for: A rare, inherited bone disorder marked by low levels of phosphate in the blood; A rare disorder that can lead to bone and kidney damage; Underactive parathyroid; Softening of the bones; A bone disorder that occurs in people with kidney disease; Rickets; Vitamin D deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Cavities; Heart failure; Infection of the airways; Preventing tooth loss; Weak and brittle bones; Psoriasis
Possibly Effective for: Cavities; Heart failure; Infection of the airways; Preventing tooth loss; Weak and brittle bones; Psoriasis
Vitamin B1
1.5 mg
Effective for: Metabolic disorders; Thiamine deficiency; Brain disorder due to thiamine deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Cataracts; Kidney disease in people with diabetes; Painful menstruation
Possibly Effective for: Cataracts; Kidney disease in people with diabetes; Painful menstruation
Vitamin B3
20 mg
Effective for: Abnormal levels of blood fats; Treatment and prevention of niacin deficiency, and certain conditions related to niacin deficiency such as pellagra
Possibly Effective for: Metabolic syndrome; Abnormal levels of blood fats
Possibly Effective for: Metabolic syndrome; Abnormal levels of blood fats
Vitamin B9
400 mcg
Effective for: Folate deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Depression; High blood pressure; Gum disease in women who are pregnant; Stroke; Serious kidney disease ; Toxicity caused by the drug methotrexate; Birth defects of the brain and spine
Possibly Effective for: Depression; High blood pressure; Gum disease in women who are pregnant; Stroke; Serious kidney disease ; Toxicity caused by the drug methotrexate; Birth defects of the brain and spine
Vitamin B7
300 mcg
Effective for: Biotin deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Biotin deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Biotin deficiency
Phosphorus
200 mg
Magnesium
80 mg
Effective for: Constipation; Indigestion; Seizures in women with pre-eclampsia; Low levels of magnesium in the blood; A pregnancy complication marked by high blood pressure and protein in the urine
Possibly Effective for: Irregular heartbeat; Asthma; Nerve pain in people with cancer; Cerebral palsy; Chronic fatigue syndrome; Cluster headache; Colon cancer, rectal cancer; Heart disease; Cystic fibrosis; Diabetes; Fibromyalgia; Hearing loss; High cholesterol; A disease of heart valves; Weak and brittle bones; Pain after surgery; Premenstrual syndrome; Chest pain due to blood vessel spasms; A type of irregular heartbeat
Possibly Effective for: Irregular heartbeat; Asthma; Nerve pain in people with cancer; Cerebral palsy; Chronic fatigue syndrome; Cluster headache; Colon cancer, rectal cancer; Heart disease; Cystic fibrosis; Diabetes; Fibromyalgia; Hearing loss; High cholesterol; A disease of heart valves; Weak and brittle bones; Pain after surgery; Premenstrual syndrome; Chest pain due to blood vessel spasms; A type of irregular heartbeat
Selenium
21 mcg
Effective for: Selenium deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Selenium deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Selenium deficiency
Chromium
18 mcg
Effective for: Chromium deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Diabetes
Possibly Effective for: Diabetes
Vitamin C
60 mg
Effective for: Vitamin C deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Protein in the urine; Irregular heartbeat; Emptying the colon before a colonoscopy; Common cold; Airway infections caused by exercise; Swelling of the stomach; Gout; High cholesterol; High blood pressure; Lead poisoning; Osteoarthritis; Pain after surgery; Sunburn; Wrinkled skin
Possibly Effective for: Protein in the urine; Irregular heartbeat; Emptying the colon before a colonoscopy; Common cold; Airway infections caused by exercise; Swelling of the stomach; Gout; High cholesterol; High blood pressure; Lead poisoning; Osteoarthritis; Pain after surgery; Sunburn; Wrinkled skin
Iron
4.5 mg
Effective for: Low levels of red blood cells in people with a long-term illness; Low levels of healthy red blood cells due to iron deficiency; Low iron levels in women who are pregnant
Possibly Effective for: Memory and thinking skills; Heart failure
Possibly Effective for: Memory and thinking skills; Heart failure
Vitamin E
30 IU
Effective for: An inherited condition that affects motor control; Vitamin E deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Alzheimer disease; Menstrual cramps; A type of non-cancerous skin sore; Bleeding within the skull; Parkinson disease; Recovery from laser eye surgery; Premenstrual syndrome; Physical performance in elderly adults; Rheumatoid arthritis; Sunburn; Swelling of the eye
Possibly Effective for: Alzheimer disease; Menstrual cramps; A type of non-cancerous skin sore; Bleeding within the skull; Parkinson disease; Recovery from laser eye surgery; Premenstrual syndrome; Physical performance in elderly adults; Rheumatoid arthritis; Sunburn; Swelling of the eye
Vitamin B2
1.7 mg
Effective for: Preventing and treating low riboflavin levels
Possibly Effective for: Cataracts; Migraine headaches
Possibly Effective for: Cataracts; Migraine headaches
Vitamin B6
2 mg
Effective for: Seizures; A condition in which the body makes abnormal red blood cells that build up iron ; Vitamin B6 deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Hardening of the arteries ; Kidney stones; Morning sickness; Premenstrual syndrome
Possibly Effective for: Hardening of the arteries ; Kidney stones; Morning sickness; Premenstrual syndrome
Vitamin B12
6 mcg
Effective for: Inherited Vitamin B12 deficiency; Pernicious anemia; Vitamin B12 deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Canker sores; Nerve damage from shingles; Cyanide poisoning; High level of homocysteine in the blood
Possibly Effective for: Canker sores; Nerve damage from shingles; Cyanide poisoning; High level of homocysteine in the blood
Vitamin B5
10 mg
Effective for: Pantothenic acid deficiency
Possibly Effective for:
Possibly Effective for:
Iodine
150 mg
Effective for: Iodine deficiency; Radiation exposure; Thyroid conditions; Leg ulcers
Possibly Effective for: Catheter-related infection; Conjunctivitis; Foot ulcers in diabetes; Inflammation of the uterus; Painful fibrous breast tissue; Breast pain; Soreness and swelling inside the mouth; Gum infection; Surgery; Radiation exposure; Thyroid conditions; Leg ulcers
Possibly Effective for: Catheter-related infection; Conjunctivitis; Foot ulcers in diabetes; Inflammation of the uterus; Painful fibrous breast tissue; Breast pain; Soreness and swelling inside the mouth; Gum infection; Surgery; Radiation exposure; Thyroid conditions; Leg ulcers
Zinc
15 mg
Effective for: Zinc deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Acne; A disorder of zinc deficiency; An eating disorder; Burns; Common cold; Depression; Foot sores in people with diabetes; Diaper rash; A mild form of gum disease; Bad breath; Cold sores; Reduced ability to taste; Leprosy; Muscle cramps; Weak and brittle bones; Stomach ulcers; Sore throat; Pneumonia; Preterm birth; Bed sores; Sickle cell disease; Vitamin A deficiency; Warts; Diarrhea
Possibly Effective for: Acne; A disorder of zinc deficiency; An eating disorder; Burns; Common cold; Depression; Foot sores in people with diabetes; Diaper rash; A mild form of gum disease; Bad breath; Cold sores; Reduced ability to taste; Leprosy; Muscle cramps; Weak and brittle bones; Stomach ulcers; Sore throat; Pneumonia; Preterm birth; Bed sores; Sickle cell disease; Vitamin A deficiency; Warts; Diarrhea
Manganese
5 mg
Effective for: Manganese deficiency
Possibly Effective for:
Possibly Effective for:
Molybdenum
18.75 mcg
Effective for: Molybdenum deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Molybdenum deficiency
Possibly Effective for: Molybdenum deficiency
Maybe Interesting
Advantage Shake Atkins
Energy Shake Nature's Plus